photo #9324098

Most of us did follow the advice. In the spring of 2020, Americans took the two weeks seriously. We stayed home, we wiped down the groceries, we clapped for nurses. That was not defiance. That was trust.Then two weeks became two years.What started as a public health request turned into something Americans had never lived under. Churches padlocked while liquor stores stayed open. A paddleboarder arrested alone in the ocean. Sand dumped into an empty skate park. Neighbors encouraged to report neighbors. That is not a health measure, that is a posture toward free people, and it felt like a different country.The damage was not evenly spread, and it was not small.Grandparents died alone with a phone held up to a window. Family businesses that took thirty years to build were declared nonessential, while the big box store down the road was declared essential and posted record numbers. A generation of kids lost ground in reading and math that the test scores show they still have not recovered. Teen mental health fell off a cliff and has not fully climbed back.And here is the part that should end the argument.The states that reopened early did not pay the price we were told they would pay. Compare Florida to California. Adjust for age, because Florida is much older, and the outcomes land close to even. Florida kept its schools, its jobs, and its church doors. California kept its restrictions and got roughly the same result.So a pardon is exactly backward.A pardon closes the file. It says the question is settled and we are moving on. But nothing was settled, nothing was fixed, and the emergency powers that made all of it possible are still sitting on the shelf waiting for the next emergency.We do not need forgiveness handed out in advance. We need a full public accounting, so the next time someone reaches for that shelf, the American people already know the answer.