Jimmy
on November 13, 2025
12 views
Yankee Grandma Gingerbread Cookies 🎄
Old New England molasses gingerbread with a whisper of dark rum, crisp edges and tender centers
Dry:
3¾ c (450g) flour • 1 tsp baking powder • ½ tsp baking soda • 1 tsp salt • 2 tsp cinnamon • 2 tsp ginger • ¼ tsp cloves • Optional: pinch fine black pepper (true old-Yankee touch)
Wet:
12 Tbsp (170g) butter • ¾ c (160g) dark brown sugar • ¾ c (255g) unsulphured molasses • 1 Tbsp dark rum • 1 egg
Method:
Melt butter → whisk in sugar, molasses + rum → cool → beat in egg.
Whisk dry; stir into wet.
Divide, wrap, chill 1–24 hrs.
Roll ⅛” (crisp) or ¼” (chewy). Bake 350°F, 8–12 min until edges set.
Optional glaze: 1 c powdered sugar + 1–2 Tbsp lemon juice Or decorate with royal icing
Notes:
Use unsulphured molasses, not blackstrap.
Pepper = the old Rhode Island trick.
Overnight chill = deeper flavor.
Dimension: 1024 x 1434
File Size: 378.46 Kb
Like (1)
Loading...
1
Lori Dunnam
I have saved this recipe and will give it a try. I am aiming to get soft and chewy cookies. Thanks.
1
1
November 13, 2025
Lori Dunnam
Lori Dunnam replied - 2 replies